Natursutten Pacifier Review: Natural Rubber vs. Silicone for Your Baby

When you're choosing a pacifier for your little one, the material and design can make a big difference in comfort, safety, and how easily your baby accepts it. Natursutten has built a reputation for making pacifiers from natural rubber, but they also offer silicone options. This review breaks down the key differences between Natursutten natural rubber and silicone pacifiers, covering the round shield design, newborn suitability, orthodontic shape, cleaning needs, and shield size considerations.

We'll look at real-world factors like durability, taste, and how each material holds up to daily use. Whether you're a first-time parent or adding to your collection, understanding these differences will help you pick the right pacifier for your baby's needs.

Natural Rubber vs. Silicone: Material Differences

Natursutten's natural rubber pacifiers are made from 100% natural rubber tree latex, free from BPA, PVC, and phthalates. The rubber has a soft, flexible feel that many babies find comforting, and it warms to body temperature quickly. However, natural rubber can develop a slight taste or smell over time, especially if not cleaned properly. It also tends to wear out faster than silicone, so you may need to replace it more often.

Silicone pacifiers from Natursutten are made from medical-grade silicone, which is clear, odorless, and tasteless. Silicone is more durable and resistant to heat and chewing, making it a good choice for older babies with teeth. The downside is that silicone is firmer and less flexible than natural rubber, so some newborns may reject it initially. Both materials are orthodontic-friendly, but the natural rubber's softness can be more forgiving for a baby's developing palate.

• Natural rubber: soft, flexible, warms to body temp, may develop taste/smell, less durable.
• Silicone: clear, odorless, tasteless, durable, firmer feel, great for older babies.

Round Shield Design and Shield Size Options

Natursutten pacifiers feature a round shield that is designed to allow airflow and prevent skin irritation. The shield is one-piece with the nipple, so there are no crevices for bacteria to hide. This design also helps the pacifier stay in place without pressing too hard on your baby's cheeks. The round shape is symmetrical, so you don't have to worry about orientation when popping it in your baby's mouth.

Shield size is an important consideration. Natursutten offers two sizes: 0-6 months (smaller shield) and 6-18 months (larger shield). The smaller shield is ideal for newborns and smaller babies, while the larger size provides better coverage for older infants. The round shield is comfortable and doesn't dig into the skin, but some parents find it can leave a red mark if the pacifier is used for extended periods. Always check that the shield is large enough to prevent your baby from putting the entire pacifier in their mouth.

• One-piece design prevents bacteria buildup.
• Symmetrical round shield means no wrong way to insert.
• Two sizes: 0-6 months and 6-18 months.

Orthodontic Shape and Newborn Suitability

Both Natursutten natural rubber and silicone pacifiers are orthodontically designed to support healthy oral development. The nipple is flattened and shaped to mimic the breast, which can help reduce the risk of dental issues later on. The natural rubber version is especially soft, making it a great choice for newborns who are still getting used to sucking. The flexibility of the rubber allows the nipple to move naturally with your baby's tongue.

For newborns, the natural rubber pacifier is often preferred because it feels more like a breast or finger. The silicone version, while still orthodontic, is firmer and may be less appealing to very young babies. If your baby is a few months old and has started teething, the silicone option can withstand chewing better. Many parents find that starting with natural rubber and switching to silicone as the baby grows works well.

• Orthodontic shape supports healthy palate development.
• Natural rubber is softer and more newborn-friendly.
• Silicone is better for teething and older babies.

Cleaning and Care Tips for Natursutten Pacifiers

Proper cleaning extends the life of any pacifier and keeps your baby safe. For Natursutten natural rubber pacifiers, avoid boiling or using harsh detergents, as heat can degrade the rubber. Instead, wash with warm soapy water and a soft brush, then rinse thoroughly. You can also use a steam sterilizer, but keep the exposure short. Natural rubber should be replaced every 4-6 weeks, or sooner if you notice stickiness, cracks, or changes in texture.

Silicone Natursutten pacifiers are more heat-resistant and can be boiled for 5 minutes or placed in a dishwasher (top rack) for easy cleaning. They are also less prone to absorbing odors. However, silicone can still develop tiny tears over time, especially if your baby has teeth. Inspect silicone pacifiers regularly and replace them if you see any damage. Both materials should be stored in a clean, dry case when not in use.

• Natural rubber: wash with warm soapy water, avoid boiling, replace every 4-6 weeks.
• Silicone: boil or dishwasher-safe, inspect for tears, replace as needed.
• Always store in a clean case.

Real-World Experience with Natursutten Pacifiers

Many parents report that Natursutten pacifiers are well-accepted by babies, especially the natural rubber version. The softness and flexibility seem to mimic the feel of a mother's skin, which can help with soothing. The round shield is a favorite among parents who dislike the bulky heart-shaped shields on other brands. However, some note that the natural rubber can develop a slight rubbery smell after a few weeks, which is normal but can be off-putting to some babies.

In terms of durability, silicone outlasts natural rubber, but both materials are generally reliable. The orthodontic shape is praised by pediatric dentists and lactation consultants. If you're looking for a pacifier that pairs well with other baby essentials, you might also consider the Sleeping Baby Friendly Fox Zippy Swaddle or the Sleeping Baby EverSoftTM Bamboo Zipadee-Zip Swaddle Transition (Sunshine) for a complete sleep routine. The combination of a comfortable pacifier and a safe sleep sack can help your baby settle more easily.

• Natural rubber is soft and well-accepted by most babies.
• Silicone lasts longer and is easier to clean.
• Pair with a sleep sack like the Zipadee-Zip for a soothing bedtime routine.

Choosing between Natursutten natural rubber and silicone pacifiers comes down to your baby's age, sensitivity, and your cleaning preferences. Natural rubber offers a soft, flexible feel ideal for newborns, while silicone provides durability and ease of cleaning for older babies. The round shield design and orthodontic shape make both options safe and comfortable. Remember to replace pacifiers regularly and always check for signs of wear. For a holistic sleep approach, consider pairing your Natursutten pacifier with a trusted sleep sack like the Zipadee-Zip to create a consistent, calming bedtime routine.